Comparison19 November 20264 min read

Looking for a MacWhisper alternative for translated video subtitles?

MacWhisper is one of the best Mac apps for turning speech into text. But if your job is subtitles for a video, in several languages, without sending the file anywhere, you may want a tool built for that. Here's an honest comparison. I made MLX Caption, so read it with that in mind.

Short answer

Side by side

MacWhisperMLX Caption
Built forTranscripts, meetings, dictationVideo subtitles in many languages
Speech to textWhisper models, on your MacWhisper large-v3 turbo, on your Mac
TranslationTranslates transcripts and subtitles (see their site for which languages and services)Up to 100 languages with Gemma 3, on your Mac
Subtitle filesSRT, VTTSRT, VTT, text transcript
Video outputPlays the video with subtitles in the appMP4 with every language as a selectable track, or burned in
ExtrasMeeting recording, system-wide dictation, AI servicesScene descriptions, summary with chapter timestamps
PriceFree version; Pro €64 once (their site, Nov 2026)First 5 videos free, then $49 once
Mac neededSee their siteApple silicon (M1 or newer), macOS 14 or newer

Where MacWhisper is the better choice

If you record calls, write by voice, or just want a clean transcript of a podcast, MacWhisper has more for you. It records meetings, works as dictation in any app, and the free version covers basic transcription. MLX Caption does none of that. It's a subtitle tool.

Where MLX Caption fits better

Many languages in one pass. You pick the languages, and one run gives you subtitles in each of them, timed to the speech. For a course, a product video or a YouTube channel with viewers abroad, that's the whole job done at once.

Nothing leaves your Mac. Speech recognition, translation and scene descriptions all run on the Mac's own chip through Apple's MLX framework. After the first model download, it works offline. That matters for client videos, interviews and anything under an NDA.

A video file that's ready to share. Besides SRT and VTT, it exports an MP4 where every language is a subtitle track viewers can switch between, or with one language burned in.

A summary with chapters. You also get a short summary and chapter timestamps you can paste into a YouTube description.

Where MLX Caption falls short

Try it on your own video

The first 5 videos are free with every feature, so you can test it on real work before paying anything.

Sources

Written by Tabish Hassan, the developer of MLX Caption. Spotted something out of date about either app? Email hello@tabishapps.com and I'll fix it.